Substack is a newsletter publishing platform that has quickly gained popularity among writers looking for a new way to monetize their content. While it offers many benefits, such as creative freedom and the ability to build a loyal audience, there are also downsides to using Substack. In this article, we will explore some of the potential drawbacks of the platform and what writers should consider before starting a Substack newsletter.
One of the biggest downsides of using Substack is the revenue share. Substack takes a 10% cut of all subscription revenue, which can be a significant amount for small creators. Additionally, users have limited options for monetizing their content, as Substack does not offer advertising or sponsorship opportunities. Another potential issue is the lack of control over the platform. While Substack allows writers to publish their content independently, they are still subject to the platform’s terms of service and can be deplatformed if they violate them.
Despite these potential downsides, Substack remains a popular choice for writers looking to build a following and monetize their content. By weighing the pros and cons, writers can make an informed decision about whether Substack is the right platform for them. In the following sections, we will delve deeper into the potential drawbacks of Substack and what writers should consider before starting a newsletter on the platform.
- What is Substack?
- Benefits of Starting a Substack Newsletter
- Substack Pros and Cons
- How to Create a Substack Newsletter
Limitations of the Substack Model
Substack is a popular platform for writers who want to monetize their content through email newsletters. However, there are some limitations to the Substack model that writers should consider before committing to the platform.
Lack of Customization Options
One major limitation of Substack is the lack of customization options available to users. While Substack allows writers to add their own branding and customize the layout of their newsletters to some extent, it doesn’t offer the same level of control as a self-hosted website or blog.
For example, writers may want to customize the design of their newsletter beyond the options that Substack provides. They may also want to add additional features or functionality to their newsletter that Substack doesn’t support.
While there are some workarounds for these limitations, such as using custom code or integrating with other tools, they can be time-consuming and require technical knowledge that not all writers have.
Limited Audience Reach
Another limitation of the Substack model is the potential for limited audience reach. While Substack has a growing user base, it’s still a relatively new platform and may not have the same reach as more established platforms like social media or traditional blogging.
Additionally, Substack’s subscription model means that writers are relying on their subscribers to share their content with others in order to grow their audience. While this can be effective, it also means that writers may need to put in more effort to promote their newsletters and attract new subscribers.
Overall, while Substack can be a great platform for writers looking to monetize their content through email newsletters, it’s important to consider the limitations of the platform before committing to it.
- How to Customize Your Substack Newsletter Design
- How to Connect Custom Domain to Substack Newsletter
- Substack Analytics: Tracking Your Newsletter’s Performance
- The Ultimate Guide to Substack Article Formatting
- How to Embed Substack Signup Form on Other Websites
Substack has been facing financial challenges since its inception. Although the platform has been successful in attracting writers and readers alike, it has been struggling with revenue and pricing issues. In this section, we will discuss the financial challenges that Substack is currently facing.
Revenue Sharing Issues
One of the main challenges that Substack is facing is revenue sharing. Substack’s revenue sharing model is straightforward: the platform takes a 10% cut of a writer’s subscription revenue. However, some writers have criticized this model, arguing that the platform should take a smaller cut or provide more value in return. Some writers have also complained about the lack of transparency regarding revenue sharing, which has led to confusion and frustration.
Another financial challenge that Substack is facing is pricing. Substack allows writers to set their own subscription prices, which can range from $5 to $100 per month. However, some writers have struggled to find the right price point, which has led to low subscription rates and revenue. Additionally, readers have complained about the high cost of some Substack subscriptions, which has led to a decrease in readership and revenue.
To address these issues, Substack has introduced new features such as Substack Notes and Substack Local, which aim to provide more value to writers and readers. Additionally, Substack has been working on improving its revenue sharing model and pricing strategy to better serve its users.
- Substack vs. Ghost
- Substack Statistics: Platform, User, Revenue Statistics
- How to Price Your Substack Newsletter
- Pausing Paid Subscriptions on Substack
- Substack vs. Patreon
Content and Censorship Issues
Substack has faced criticism for its content and censorship policies. While the platform has a hands-off approach to content moderation, there are concerns that this could lead to the spread of misinformation and hate speech.
Lack of Content Control
One of the downsides of Substack is that the platform does not have a clear content policy. This means that creators have a lot of freedom in what they publish, but it also means that there is no clear guide for what is acceptable. This can lead to confusion and inconsistency in content moderation.
Potential for Censorship
On the other hand, some users are concerned that Substack could become a platform for censorship. As the platform grows in popularity, there is a risk that it could become more susceptible to outside pressure to remove certain content. This could limit the free speech of creators and ultimately harm the platform’s reputation.
Overall, while Substack’s hands-off approach to content moderation has its benefits, it also has its downsides. As the platform continues to grow, it will be important for it to strike a balance between free speech and responsible content moderation.
- Substack Private Mode
- Substack Notes
- Can You Write Anonymously on Substack?
- Can You See Who Reads Your Substack?
Substack is a relatively new platform, and as such, it is still working out some technical difficulties. These difficulties can sometimes cause inconvenience for users and may impact the platform’s overall stability.
One of the main technical issues that users have reported is platform stability. Some users have reported experiencing occasional downtime, which can be frustrating for those who rely on the platform to publish their content. Additionally, some users have reported issues with formatting and publishing their content, which can also affect the platform’s overall stability.
Customer Support Challenges
Another issue that users have reported is customer support challenges. While Substack does offer customer support, some users have reported difficulties in getting in touch with support staff or receiving timely responses to their inquiries. This can be particularly frustrating for users who are experiencing technical difficulties or other issues with the platform.
Overall, while Substack has many benefits, it is not without its downsides. Technical difficulties can impact the platform’s stability, and customer support challenges can make it difficult for users to get the assistance they need. However, these issues are relatively minor compared to the many benefits that Substack offers.
- Substack SEO: Tips for Ranking Your Posts
- How to Contact Substack Customer Support
- How to Import Posts to Substack
- How to Connect GA4 with Substack
- How to Generate Media Assets for Each Substack Post
Lack of Community Building Tools
Substack is a great platform for creating and distributing newsletters. However, one of the downsides of Substack is the lack of community building tools. While Substack allows users to create and distribute newsletters, it does not offer many features for building and engaging with a community.
Limited Engagement Features
One of the main issues with Substack is the limited engagement features. While users can create and distribute newsletters, there are few options for engaging with readers. For example, users cannot create forums or groups for readers to discuss topics related to the newsletter. This means that readers cannot easily interact with each other or the author, which can limit the growth and engagement of the community.
Absence of Community Moderation Tools
Another issue with Substack is the absence of community moderation tools. Without these tools, it can be difficult for authors to moderate discussions and ensure that the community remains civil and respectful. This can lead to negative interactions and discourage readers from participating in the community.
To overcome these limitations, authors can use other tools to build and engage with their community. For example, they can create forums or groups on social media platforms like Facebook or Reddit. They can also use tools like Slack or Discord to create chat rooms where readers can interact with each other and the author.