Skip to Content

What Is a Good Substack Open Rate?

What Is a Good Substack Open Rate?

Substack has gained popularity as a platform for writers and creators to reach their audience through email newsletters. However, one of the biggest questions that creators face is what constitutes a good open rate for their Substack newsletter. An open rate is the percentage of subscribers who open the email and engage with the content.

Understanding open rates is an important aspect of measuring the success of a newsletter. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer to what a good open rate is, creators can benchmark their open rates against industry standards and analyze their metrics to improve their engagement rates. By analyzing open rates and experimenting with different strategies, creators can increase their chances of reaching their audience and building a loyal subscriber base.

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding open rates is crucial for measuring the success of a Substack newsletter.
  • Creators can benchmark their open rates against industry standards to gauge their performance.
  • Analyzing open rate metrics and experimenting with different strategies can help improve engagement rates and build a loyal subscriber base.

Understanding Open Rates

Definition of Open Rate

Open rate is the percentage of subscribers who opened an email or newsletter. It is calculated by dividing the number of email opens by the number of emails sent, excluding bounces. Open rates are a valuable metric for understanding how engaged your subscribers are with your content.

Importance of Open Rates in Substack

Open rates are particularly important for Substack newsletters because they can be an indication of subscriber engagement and potential revenue. Higher open rates can lead to more paid subscriptions and a larger audience. However, it is important to keep in mind that open rates are not a perfect measure of subscriber engagement as some subscribers may read your newsletter without opening the email or notification.

To improve open rates, Substack creators can try various strategies such as targeting their audience, optimizing their subject lines, and sending newsletters at optimal times. Additionally, it is important to provide valuable and engaging content to keep subscribers interested and coming back for more.

In summary, open rates are an important metric for Substack creators to track and improve. By understanding what open rates are and how they are calculated, creators can make informed decisions about their newsletter strategy and content.

Benchmarking Substack Open Rates

Industry Standards

Substack open rates vary widely depending on the niche, audience, and content of the newsletter. According to a recent survey, the average open rate for Substack newsletters is around 50%. However, some newsletters can achieve an open rate of 70% or higher, while others struggle to reach 20%.

To get a better sense of what is considered a good open rate for your niche, it is a good idea to benchmark your performance against other newsletters in your industry. You can use tools like Mailchimp’s Email Marketing Benchmarks or Campaign Monitor’s Email Marketing Benchmarks to see how your open rate compares to others in your industry.

Factors Affecting Benchmarks

Several factors can affect your Substack open rate, including the following:

  • Subject Line: The subject line is the first thing that subscribers see in their inbox. A compelling subject line can encourage subscribers to open the email, while a boring or misleading subject line can lead to lower open rates.

  • Content Quality: The quality of your newsletter content can also have a significant impact on your open rate. If your content is useful, engaging, and relevant to your audience, they are more likely to open and read your emails.

  • Frequency: The frequency of your newsletter can also impact your open rate. If you send too many emails, subscribers may get annoyed and stop opening them. On the other hand, if you don’t send enough emails, subscribers may forget about your newsletter and stop opening them.

  • List Size: The size of your email list can also affect your open rate. Smaller lists may have higher open rates because subscribers feel more connected to the author and are more likely to open their emails. Larger lists, on the other hand, may have lower open rates because subscribers are less engaged and may not remember subscribing in the first place.

By considering these factors and benchmarking your open rate against others in your industry, you can get a better sense of what is considered a good Substack open rate for your newsletter.

Improving Your Substack Open Rate

If you’re struggling to get your Substack open rates up, there are a few tactics you can try to improve engagement with your audience. Here are some strategies to consider:

Crafting Engaging Subject Lines

One of the most important factors in getting people to open your emails is crafting attention-grabbing subject lines. Avoid using generic subject lines that don’t give readers a clear idea of what they can expect from your email. Instead, try to be specific and descriptive, while also keeping things concise. Consider using action-oriented language or asking a question to pique readers’ curiosity.

Segmenting Your Audience

Another way to boost your open rates is by segmenting your email list. By dividing your subscribers into different groups based on factors like their interests or engagement history, you can tailor your email content to better meet their needs. This can help improve the relevance of your emails and make them more likely to be opened and read.

Optimizing Send Times

Finally, consider experimenting with the timing of your email sends. Depending on your audience, certain days and times may be more effective than others. For example, if you’re targeting busy professionals, sending emails during the workday may not be ideal. Instead, try sending emails in the early morning or evening when people are more likely to have downtime. Keep in mind that the best send times may vary depending on your audience and the content of your emails, so be willing to experiment and adjust your strategy as needed.

By implementing these strategies, you can work towards improving your Substack open rates and building a more engaged audience. Remember to track your results and adjust your approach as needed to find what works best for your specific situation.

Analyzing Open Rate Metrics

Tools for Tracking Opens

Substack provides a few metrics to help users track their open rates. One of these metrics is the open rate, which is the percentage of people who opened a post after receiving an email or Substack app notification about it. Additionally, Substack also tracks link clicks, which is the percentage of openers who clicked a given link in the post and the total click count.

Substack detects opens by watching users load the images in their messages or opening a post after receiving a mobile app notification about it. Often this happens when the user clicks an email, but sometimes images can load in previews, or even be eagerly loaded by email clients for messages at the top of a user’s mailbox.

Interpreting Data

While open rates are an important metric to track, it is important to interpret the data in the context of the specific Substack newsletter. For instance, a newsletter with a smaller subscriber list may have a higher open rate than a newsletter with a larger subscriber list. This is because smaller lists often have more engaged subscribers who are more likely to open emails.

Another factor to consider when interpreting open rate data is the frequency of posts. A newsletter that posts less frequently may have a higher open rate than one that posts more frequently. This is because subscribers may be more likely to open emails from a newsletter that they do not receive as often.

Overall, while open rates are an important metric to track, it is important to interpret the data in the context of the specific newsletter and to use other metrics such as conversion rates and revenue generated to fully understand the effectiveness of the newsletter.

Case Studies and Success Stories

Several Substack users have achieved impressive open rates by implementing effective strategies. Here are a few case studies:

  • Case Study 1: A blogger who writes about personal finance achieved an open rate of 67% by sending a weekly newsletter to a list of 5,000 subscribers. The blogger attributes this success to the following factors: high-quality content that resonates with the audience, a clear and concise subject line, and consistent delivery on the same day and time each week.

  • Case Study 2: A writer who covers technology news achieved an open rate of 58% by segmenting their list into two groups: subscribers who had opened at least one newsletter in the past 30 days, and subscribers who had not. The writer sent a different subject line to each group, resulting in higher open rates for both segments. Additionally, the writer experimented with sending newsletters at different times of day to determine the optimal send time for their audience.

  • Case Study 3: A podcast host who interviews entrepreneurs achieved an open rate of 52% by including a teaser of the guest’s story in the subject line. For example, instead of using a generic subject line like “New Episode of XYZ Podcast,” the host used a subject line like “How Jane Smith Built a Million-Dollar Business From Scratch.” This approach piqued the curiosity of subscribers and led to higher open rates.

These case studies demonstrate that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to achieving a good Substack open rate. However, by focusing on high-quality content, clear and concise subject lines, consistent delivery, and audience segmentation, Substack users can increase the likelihood that their newsletters will be opened and read by subscribers.

Future Trends in Newsletter Engagement

As newsletters continue to gain popularity, it is important to keep an eye on future trends in newsletter engagement. One trend that has been emerging is the use of personalization to increase open rates. Personalization can include anything from addressing the subscriber by name to tailoring content to their interests.

Another trend is the use of interactive content in newsletters. This can include quizzes, polls, and surveys that encourage subscribers to engage with the content. Interactive content can help to increase open rates and keep subscribers engaged.

Additionally, as more people turn to mobile devices to read their emails, it is important to optimize newsletters for mobile. This includes using a mobile-responsive design, keeping subject lines short, and using clear and concise language.

Finally, it is important to continue to monitor open rates and engagement metrics to identify areas for improvement. By analyzing data and making changes to content and delivery strategies, creators can continue to improve their open rates and keep subscribers engaged.